You may have heard there are differences between blankets and comforters, but they may not be obvious at first glance.
The key differences are in the design: a blanket has a single layer, while comforters have two thinner layers of fabric with some form of filling inside.
Because of these differences, though, these two bedding types are more suited to different situations. So, we’ve broken down the pros and cons of each kind to help you find which side you’re on in the blanket versus comforter debate.
Here are some details about blankets (also sometimes called throw blankets!) to help you make the right call for you.
1. Suited for warmer weather
In warmer environments, a comforter may be too thick to sleep under comfortably. Since blankets only have one layer of material, they’re not as hot, letting you stay comfortable without overheating at night.
2. Can be better for those with allergies
Most comforter models have fillings, like down, that can set off allergies in some cases. (1) While there are alternatives, you’ll have much less of a hassle shopping for a hypoallergenic blanket instead.
3. Lighter weight
Again, because they have a single layer, blankets are much lighter than their comforter counterparts. This design can make a great choice if you regularly tote our blanket around the house to cuddle up or if you’re looking for something to bring along when you travel.
On the other hand, blankets can be heavier than comforters if they’re “weighted blankets.”
Weighted blankets usually range around 10-15 pounds, but their sleep enhancing abilities often justify why they’re so expensive.
4. Simple to wash
The smaller size of blankets makes them easy to tuck into a washer when it needs cleaning. Depending on the blanket’s material, you may need to air dry it instead of tossing it in the machine, but it’s still much better than needing to meet special washing conditions.
5. Comes in different materials
The different available materials of blankets mean that you get your choice of texture and feel, just like you’ll get with our top-rated pillows for back sleepers.
You can also pick your material choice based on your sleeping temperature preference – aka something slightly warmer or cooler.
1. Not warm enough for chilly conditions
If you live in a colder climate, then a blanket alone likely won’t be warm enough to keep you comfortable. A comforter is more of your best bet.
2. May need to layer up to stay comfortable
An alternate is to layer up with blankets to keep cozy, but purchasing multiple blankets can add up in terms of cost. This approach can also make it harder to coordinate the design of your bed set.
3. Some materials can wear down over time
Not all blankets are made durable, unfortunately, so they can definitely wear down over time with regular use. While the quality of the make and fabric material will impact this, you may find yourself more quickly needing a replacement than if you’d used a top-rated comforter.
And for the other end of the blanket versus comforter discussion, here are the pros and cons of comforters.
1. Much warmer than blankets
The design is all about keeping you warm. As you probably know, three layers are usually always going to beat a blanket’s single layer when it comes to keeping you toasty, as long as you keep the materials the same. As such, they’re a better match for living in colder environments.
2. Often come with matching bed sets
It’s not too hard to find great comforter models in a complete bed set, which means you’ll have coordinated sheets and pillowcases in one purchase. Often, these sets are also affordable.
3. Have other fillings
All comforters have fillings which help provide the warmth you get from these covers. Some options include down, synthetic fibers, wool, cotton, and more. (2) Those with allergies have options that won’t set them off, and the filling can also impact the price, letting you find a choice in your budget.
4. Can have reversible designs
Another design plus of comforters is that they can have reversible fabric designs, with one on each side. This effectively gives you two design choices in one, which is excellent for people who like to change up the look of their bedrooms regularly to keep up with the latest top trends.
5. Have sizes to fit over your bed comfortably
Most models intend to fit over your whole bed, so it’s simple to find one the right size to match your sleeping arrangements. You may have a bit more of a challenge finding a blanket of the correct size.
1. May be too hot for some conditions
Because they are warmer to sleep under in most cases, their fabric may be too warm feeling when used in hotter living conditions. You may want to skip a comforter if you live in a more heated environment.
2. Can be challenging to wash
The larger size of a comforter can be challenging to fit into a washer easily. If nothing else, it will need a load to itself to wash correctly. Some comforters can come in materials that require dry cleaning to keep clean.
3. Not always easy to store
If you only plan to use your comforter during the winter months, you may run into the challenge of storing it away during the off season. Comforters have some bulk, which can impact how effectively they’ll fit into your storage space.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Want some more info to help you with the comforter versus blanket debate? We have answers to some commonly asked questions.
Which type of blanket is the warmest?
Out of our two options here, comforters are warmer because they have more material to help keep heat. After all, covers are simply trapping and conducting the warmth that your body puts off at night.
Looked at scientifically: “Flat fibers like those found in synthetic blankets don’t trap the warm body heat. Curly wool fibers create air pockets for the warm air to nest in, as do the pockets of air surrounding clumps of down, returning that warmth to swim over your body.” (3)
When you start comparing other blankets, the material will ultimately impact the level of warmth, with wool and fleece being some of the better options.
Which is better: comforter or blanket?
The simple answer is that comforters and blankets are better used for different situations and circumstances.
In general, a comforter is better for those who need something warm, want to coordinate with their bed set, and want their choice of fillings. On the flip side, a blanket is better if you live in a warmer environment, need something lightweight, and if you want a cover that’s easy to wash.
What is the best material for a comforter?
Comforters come with various materials as fillings that can suit different sleepers, just like our best pillows for stomach sleepers. Cotton, down, and wool are all frequent contenders for the top spot, as they help maintain heat and comfort as you sleep. Down, however, can trigger allergies for some sleepers, so it’s not a good match for them.
Bamboo is another rising comforter and blanket contender. This option is durable, comfortable, hypoallergenic, and sustainable. Producing it also has many environmental benefits – “While bamboo uses only 12 gallons of water to produce one pound of fabric, cotton requires over 200 times more.” (4)
If you plan on picking out a comforter for your bed, compare the material options to see which one fits your needs best!
Final Verdict: Comforter vs Blanket (Who Wins?)
While both comforters, and blankets ultimately serve different purposes, both can be excellent, comfortable, and well worth their salt when you use them in the right circumstances.
And if you’ve made it this far, here at Sleep.FM, in our blanket versus comforter debate, you’re well on your way to making a home-run decision.
So, now all that’s left is to find the perfect model for you to catch some quality, sweet and rejuvenating z’s!